My blog

Saturday, June 13, 2009

Et Tu Brutus? Then fall Caesar.

If the aftermath of a speech stirs an impact that becomes the content of yet another speech in future,then it can be safely termed to be a memorable one.Such speeches have no barriers of words,language or of the common tongue as the speaker rises higher than the parameters of a mortal man.

Brutus’s speech at Caesar’s funeral though overshadowed by Mark Antony’s parlance is absolutely marvelous and sadly underrated.When you commit a crime and start with an appeal to reason and order,there is a tincture of guilt that goes against what you think and what you say.Brutus’s speech lacked that guilt ending on an almost indignant note, and playing on the Roman people's regard for their civic freedoms.Maybe that’s why they say “you are not a thief until and unless you are caught “.He brilliantly praised Caesar for the person he was and at the same time justified why the cessation of his( Caesar) breaths was beneficial for his countrymen.His speech evolved around the (in)famous word “ambitious” which served its purpose to the core…that is to “damage”.It not only damaged Caesar’s reputation in the minds of his beloved Romans but was the only flaw in Brutus’s speech.With blood stains on your robes,you defend yourself under the pretext of a lover of humans?? Oh Brutus, you are heartless but I do not blame thee...For the people around chose what they wanted to see.

It is easy to make people think but very difficult to make them re-think and convince them that what they thought and believed for so long was a twisted interpretation and not a fact.Brutus did it but it was a Herculean task for Mark Antony to reiterate a reiteration!!
Mark Antony said much more than he meant and meant much more than he said.His speech was encompassed with rhetorical devices and the most deadly and ironical combination of sarcasm and euphemism.He unlike Brutus never praised Caesar rather he projected his decisions to be foolish for somebody who was crowned as an ambitious man.He never mentions the conspirators of Caesar’s death to be traitors but changes the very definition of “honourable” by changing its undertone and usage.But the word here served its purpose..that is damage again.He touched the central spot of Brutus’s speech ( “ambitious”) and crumbled the entire structure of thoughts in the minds of Romans into a worthless heap.One man’s food is another man’s poison!!He cites examples of how Caesar refused the crown thrice and how his heart bled when his countrymen suffered.Each time questioning the authenticity of the personification used by Brutus to address Caesar.
The speech of Antony served its purpose.It sowed the seeds of thoughts in the minds of the Romans,it created a turmoil in their hearts,it led to corporeal anguish but it also did what “memorable” speeches do….it never channelised and never gave a direction.It answered what,why,who etc…but never How?? It led to the death of Cinna,a poet who was mistaken as Cinna,one of the conspirators of Caesar’s death.Death of an innocent man!! I question you Antony….Don’t you have blood stains on your robes too? Are you not guilty of murder too? Claiming to be loyal to Caesar…you are the cause of one of his beloved ones ( assuming Caesar loved his countrymen as you say).To me you are no better than Brutus for you chose to show people what they didn’t want to see and when they saw it through your eyes..they were blinded!!!

O judgement,thou are fled to brutish beasts,
And men have lost their reason !

It’s amusing to spill poison about people who claimed to be righteous with my pen,
Rome was indeed full of ‘honourable’ men !!

4 comments:

  1. Of all the things under the sun u picked up two speeches after one of the most infamous murders in the history of mankind...

    I've not had a chance to read the exact version of the speech...but going by your words i agree that memorable speeches lead to a few other one's as well...
    Both brutus and antony were trying not just 2 justify themselves but were also warring with the one thing which is impossible to beat the name in some one's mind..

    As you've rightly portrayed both tried to do their best and failed in certain respects..

    I only disagree that memorable speeches do not define how to move forward...

    Last but not the least...if u right so well.. why have u started so late??

    looking forward to your posts!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely". From Caeser back in the old times to the modern day Saddam, instances have been myriad of leaders who are reluctant to relent power. They've their followers, they've their critics nd enemies.. but the cycle stays that way. I'm reminded of the Batman Movie's dialogue at this " U either die a hero, or u live long enough to see urself become a villian."

    Caeser transmogrified from Rome's Guardian angel to a Machiavellian dictator. And after his death, the bone of contention for power was obvious.

    Going by ur description( not being a literature's aficionado has prevented me from immersing into the speech yet),both men try to guage the pulse of the crowd ;as the nerve may be an ambivalence of renegade, hate,fury and bliss.

    But mark antony captured the essence to perfection..he made sure the right use of his rhetoric euphemism and his expertise at parlance are put to good use... he sends across a strong statement in a politically correct way to make sure of not being the one to be gaining out of the demise, at the same time taking a dig at the cospirators so that the crowd does frame an opinion.

    He clearly overpowers the word "ambitious" Brutus used , and made it sound fatuous.

    WHo was the conspirator is not the issue here, the issue is who understood his ppl better and i feel Mark Antony is the one here.

    Brillian work to say the least... u've evoked the curiosity in me to read the act, and this coming from someone who hardly indulges in comprehending literature is a clear testimony to ur pulchritudinous work. Its riveting, its pragmatic (tho the romantics stay unharmed) and is a pleasant change from the cliche stuff one gets to read around.

    Like ur side bar indicates now, i'm a follower of the blog now and would love to see more work coming from u. Cheers lady...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great to present a resourseful thought through an immortal story!!!kudos!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice one... loved the way it meanders :)

    ReplyDelete